S2.5.6 Chapter 6
Air and water resistance
Why does paper fall slowly when a stone falls fast?
Your guess
Pick one before you read on. It is fine to be wrong.
By the end you can
- Make paper spinners and compare how fast they fall
- Explain why fish and boats have smooth, pointed shapes
A stone falls fast. A sheet of paper falls slowly. Gravity pulls both. So why the difference?
You cannot see air, but it is there. It pushes on things that move through it.
Air resistance is the push of air against a moving thing.
Draw it first
Draw why a flat sheet falls slowly
1 Draw a flat sheet and a paper ball. Draw a gravity arrow down from each.
2 Draw a long arrow up from the sheet. Draw a short arrow up from the ball.
3 Write falls slowly under the sheet. Write falls faster under the ball.
A flat sheet meets a lot of air. The air pushes up hard. The sheet falls slowly.
Crumple the same paper. It weighs the same. But less of it meets the air. The push up is smaller. It falls faster.
A parachute has a wide canopy. It meets a lot of air, so the air pushes up hard.
This parachutist falls at a steady speed. The air pushes up as hard as gravity pulls down. The forces are balanced.
Water pushes on moving things too. Water resistance is the push of water against a moving thing. It is much stronger than air resistance.
A swimmer feels water resistance. The water pushes back against the swimmer all the time.
Fish, boats and flying birds have smooth, pointed shapes. We say they are streamlined. Water and air slide past them.
See it three ways
As a picture
In words
A flat front meets a lot of water. A pointed front meets less. The push back is smaller. The body moves on with less effort.
Try it
Make paper spinners
You need: two paper strips, each 4 cm wide and 16 cm long, a grown up with scissors, two paper clips, a friend to watch.
Be safe: A grown up uses the scissors. Do not climb on a chair or a wall to drop them.
- A grown up cuts each strip down the middle. Cut from the top to half way.
- Fold the two top flaps out. Fold one forward and one back. These are the wings.
- Fold the bottom of each strip up by 2 cm. Slide a paper clip on.
- A grown up cuts the wings of one spinner to half length.
- Hold both spinners high above your head, at the same height.
- Let go of both at the same moment. Which lands last? Try three times.
What you will see: Both spinners turn as they fall. The spinner with long wings falls more slowly. It lands last. Long wings meet more air.
A wrong idea many people have
Air is nothing, so it cannot push.
Why it feels right: You cannot see air. Your hand moves through it with no trouble.
The test that breaks it: Hold a flat piece of card in front of you. Swing it fast, flat side first. Feel the push on your hand. Now swing it edge first. The push is much smaller.
What is true: Air is real stuff. It pushes against things that move through it. A wide, flat thing meets more air.
Key words
- air resistance
- the push of air against a moving thing.
- water resistance
- the push of water against a moving thing.
- streamlined
- a smooth, pointed shape that meets little air or water.
Back to your guess
The answer is C: Air pushes up against the paper.
Air pushes up against the paper. Gravity pulls the paper, but the air slows its fall.
Check yourself
Try each one before you look. A wrong answer tells you where to go next.
Why does flat paper fall more slowly than a paper ball?
See the answer
More of the sheet meets air. So air pushes up more.
The sheet and the ball weigh the same. The sheet meets more air, so it falls more slowly.
- If you chose B: It is the same paper. Gravity pulls it the same, flat or crumpled. Go to S2.5.5.
- If you chose C: Crumpling does not change the weight. The ball just meets less air.
Mei makes two paper spinners. One has long wings. One has short wings. Which falls more slowly?
See the answer
The one with long wings
Long wings meet more air. The air pushes up harder, so the spinner falls more slowly.
- If you chose A: Short wings meet less air. The air pushes up less, so it falls faster.
- If you chose C: Wing length changes how much air they meet. Make two and test them.
You push your flat hand through air. Then you push it through water. Where is the push back bigger?
See the answer
In water
Water resistance is stronger than air resistance. You feel it at once.
- If you chose A: You can feel air push, but water pushes back much harder.
- If you chose B: Water resistance is much stronger than air resistance.
- If you chose C: Air is real stuff. Swing a flat card fast. You feel it push on your hand.
Why do fish have smooth, pointed shapes?
See the answer
Water slides past them, so the push back is small.
A pointed front meets less water. The water resistance is smaller. A fish moves on with less effort.
- If you chose A: Gravity does not care about shape. Water resistance does. Go to S2.5.5.
- If you chose B: It is the other way round. A flat front meets more water and gets pushed back harder.
From an earlier chapter
A bottle top slides on a smooth floor. It slides on a rough mat. Which makes it stop sooner?
See the answer
The rough mat
A rough surface gives more friction. More friction stops the bottle top sooner.
Draw a flat sheet of paper falling. Draw an arrow for gravity and an arrow for air resistance.
See the answer
A sheet with an arrow down for gravity. A long arrow up for the air. It is almost as long as the gravity arrow.
Gravity pulls the sheet down. The air pushes up against it, so it falls slowly.
Why does a parachute slow a fall?
See the answer
The wide canopy meets lots of air, so air pushes up hard.
A wide canopy meets much more air than a person alone. The air resistance is big, so the fall is slow.
- If you chose A: Gravity pulls the same. The wide canopy is what changes the fall. Go to S2.5.5.
- If you chose C: A parachute still falls, so it is not lighter than air. It meets a lot of air, and the air pushes up.
A parachutist falls at a steady speed. The picture shows only the weight. What does the air do?
See the answer
It pushes up as hard as the weight pulls down.
A steady speed means the forces are balanced. The air pushes up as hard as gravity pulls down.
- If you chose A: Air is real stuff. A wide canopy meets a lot of it. The air pushes back.
- If you chose B: Air resistance acts against the way a thing moves. The parachutist moves down, so it pushes up.
- If you chose C: Then the parachutist would be slowed more and more. A steady speed needs the two forces equal.
A swimmer moves through water. Look at the picture. Which way does the water push on the swimmer?
See the answer
Backwards, against the way the swimmer moves
Water resistance pushes against the way a thing moves. The swimmer moves forwards, so the push is backwards.
- If you chose A: Water does not carry a swimmer along here. It pushes against the movement.
- If you chose B: Water does push up on a swimmer. Water resistance acts against the movement.
- If you chose D: Down is the way the Earth pulls. Water resistance acts against the movement.
A feather and a stone fall from the same height. The stone lands first. Why?
See the answer
The air slows the feather much more than it slows the stone.
A feather is light and wide. The air slows it a lot. A stone is hardly slowed.
- If you chose A: Gravity pulls on everything. The feather falls more slowly because the air slows it a lot.
- If you chose C: A big stone and a small stone land together. The feather is slowed by air, not just by its weight.
Keep it
Copy this into your exercise book.
Air and water push against things that move through them. This is air resistance and water resistance. A wide, flat thing meets more, so it falls or moves slower. Fish and boats are pointed.
Draw: Draw a flat sheet and a paper ball. Add a long arrow up and a short arrow up.